Welcome to Black Dog Pizzeria
Nestled in the heart of Dublin, Ohio, Black Dog Pizzeria is a culinary haven for pizza enthusiasts. Known for its Columbus-style thin, crispy crust, each pizza is crafted edge-to-edge with premium mozzarella and an array of fresh toppings. The menu tantalizes with intriguing dishes like the Pizza of the Month, Springer Spaniel, featuring gourmet ingredients that elevate traditional flavors. Diners rave about delightful starters like garlic knots and Buffalo chicken dip, perfectly complementing their thoughtfully curated pies. The welcoming ambiance and attentive service make Black Dog a community favorite, where every visit is a celebration of quality and taste.
-
5923 Karric Square Dr, Dublin, OH 43016 Hotline: (614) 734-0758
Welcome to the culinary adventure that is Black Dog Pizzeria, your go-to spot for mouthwatering pizza, crisp salads, and delectable chicken wings. Nestled in the heart of Dublin, Ohio at 5923 Karric Square Dr, this pizzeria stands out not just for its location but also for its commitment to quality and community. With a reputation for friendly service and delicious food, it’s no wonder that Black Dog is quickly becoming a favorite among local pizza lovers.
One of the highlights at Black Dog Pizzeria is their customizable 14” Columbus-style pizzas, featuring a thin, crispy crust that is perfectly topped edge-to-edge and square cut. Made with high-quality mozzarella cheese, these pizzas allow patrons to create their own masterpiece—just remember, pepperoni is an optional extra, so choose wisely! Customers rave about how the crispy texture complements their favorite toppings.
- Garlic Knots: Six large knots baked to perfection, tossed in garlic butter and served with red sauce for dipping, priced at just $7.75.
- Pretzel Bites: Buttery bites served warm with house-made queso—perfect for sharing (or not!) at $9.75.
- Pizza of the Month: Treat yourself to the unique flavors of the "Springer Spaniel"—a delightful mix of garlic, shallots, goat cheese, and mushrooms, drizzled with balsamic vinaigrette for just $19.95.
The ambiance at Black Dog Pizzeria adds to the dining experience. The owners foster a welcoming environment, making sure every customer feels like part of the family. The consistently positive customer feedback highlights this: "Love this pizza!! And the customer service is just as good!" exclaims Valerie W., while Andrius S. praises the pizza craftsmanship, claiming it to be "one of the best" he has ever had.
Though a few customers pointed out inconsistencies with takeout orders, the overwhelming majority express satisfaction with the quality of ingredients and flavor. As noted by Carrissa T., her pie packed with delicious toppings was "SO good!" and a must-try for anyone venturing into this gem of a restaurant.
In a recent resurgence after temporarily closing due to unforeseen circumstances, Black Dog Pizzeria has proven itself resilient and more committed than ever to serve up exceptional food. If you find yourself in Dublin, do not miss the chance to indulge in their culinary creations. It’s not just a meal; it’s an experience baked into every bite!
To place an order or learn more, you can reach Black Dog at (614) 734-0758. Discover your new favorite pizza spot today!
One of our new fav pizza spots! Have tried at least 4 different pizzas and have yet to be disappointed! Did a "make your own" this week, Columbus style with pep sausage ricotta and basil with hot honey. SO good!
Love this pizza!! And the customer service is just as good! NY style is my favorite but you can't go wrong with Columbus either.
Got takeout so I'm unable to evaluate the bathroom, but I'm sure it's nice. This pizzeria caught my eye due to some dedicated foodies on the FB page and one of the owners sharing pictures of their delicious pies. I gotta say, I was not disappointed. The pizza has that classic crispy texture of NY style pizzas without being overly cracker-ish that I see in these more tavern style pies. I really liked the sauce and they were very generous with the peps. The price seems about average but that's a plus since I think the food has quality. The staff are lovely humans and even address by name at the counter. I really liked the ambiance Overall. Overall i'd give it a 3.8/5, Im excited to go back and try some of their other styles!!
I've had Black Dog now a few times. Typically have it delivered via a third party. It's a good price and ingredients seem to be high quality. My only knock is that it has been a bit inconsistent in my orders. Sometimes it's shown up perfect then other times it looks like it was just thrown together and shoved in an oven.
This is our favorite pizza in Columbus! The garlic knots are next level! We got two orders tonight! The service is always fantastic! Such a cute shop too!!
Passing through town from Chicago. Read the reviews and decided to give Black Dog a try. The staff was great! Warm welcome and made sure everyone waiting for an order was taken care of. I ordered the Ultimutt and a small house salad. The house salad was good size for a small, generous, and filled with fresh veggies, lettuce and pepperoni. It was delicious. The pizza was OUTSTANDING. One of the best I've ever had. It was loaded with fresh ingredients and the tomato sauce was awesome! If I'm ever back in the Dublin area, I will definitely be back!
What an absolutely underrated gem! I was looking for pizza in the Hilliard/Dublin area and saw Black Dog on the map. I had never heard of it but saw good reviews and the menu looked delicious so decided to go for it. Now I'm sad that I live on the other side of town away from it! I can't remember the name of the pizza we had but it was a white style pizza with onions. We also had garlic knots and Angie's rainbow cookies which were both delicious. I will definitely be ordering again and have recommended Black Dog to others!
Great food delivered! Priced right! Fresh salad and toppings a new favorite! Served hot!
The BEST pizza in Columbus. Absolutely love Black Dog. Could not be more thrilled that they are back open. I have several favorites but Atta Boy squeaks by as my #1, delicious. I like it New York style. You can not go wrong with any choice! Owners are super kind! Community involved. And always happy to answer pizza questions. If you delicious and fresh...this is your place.
I was sad to hear they were closed for 5 months due to a fire. Now that they are reopened, we decided to order some pizza for delivery. When ordering online, it will redirect you to the "Slice" app, which is relatively easy to use/place your order. It gives you an ETA but it's not 100% accurate. Our order ended up being delivered even though the app still said they were "prepping it". Even though it got delivered sooner than expected, the food was not hot when it got here, more like warm. We love their Cujo, NY style pizza. The flavors are great - pepperoni, bacon, mushrooms, topped with hot honey! I also decided to try their cheesy pesto sticks. I was a little disappointed when I didn't see a sauce since the menu stated it came with a side of pizza sauce. I'm not sure if they forgot to pack it in my order but my palate was really searching for it while I was eating the sticks. Without the sauce, the cheese sticks are good, with a mild pesto flavor, but they are very dry. They have a good crunch to them though!